by Robert Novy-Marx, University of Rochester/NBER
and Joshua D. Rauh, Kellogg School of Management/ NBER
dated June 2011
dated June 2011
The following tables are excerpted: (GSP = Gross State Product)
Contributions, Payroll, and Revenues for State and Local Systems
Government Contributions Incl Social Security
Total Payroll Revenues % of GSP per household
New York $65.8 Billions 1.2% $1,738.8
Rhode Island $2.4 1.3% $1,557.3
Hawaii $3.7 1.1% $1,436.4
Virginia $17.5 1.0% $1,374.0
California $108.1 1.0% $1,368.8
Alaska $2.3 0.7% $1,234.7
Illinois $29.3 1.0% $1,215.3
New Mexico $4.7 1.2% $1,180.6
Nevada $5.2 0.9% $1,147.2
New Jersey $26.9 0.7% $1,078.0
Gvt Contributions Required Contribution Increase
Current($B) Total Required Revenue % of GSP per household
New Jersey $3.6 $11.9 1.7% $2,475
New York $13.1 $30.0 1.5% $2,250
Oregon $1.3 $4.4 1.9% $2,140
Wyoming $0.2 $0.6 1.2% $2,080
Ohio $3.1 $12.2 1.9% $2,051
California $19.5 $47.8 1.5% $1,994
Minnesota $1.7 $5.6 1.5% $1,928
Illinois $6.0 $15.5 1.5% $1,907
New York State is the overall winner, when you add the numbers from each table to get the total spending required. And things are worse than they appear because many of the households in New York don't pay taxes, so the $2,250 additional tax required per taxpaying household per year increases. NY Comptroller reports 4.52 million residents out of the total 19.4 million NYS population are Medicaid eligible and thus unable to contribute
Oh, somewhere in our favored land the sun is shining bright;
The band is playing somewhere, and somewhere hearts are light,
And somewhere men are laughing, and somewhere children shout;
But here in New York, the taxpayers will strike out
No comments:
Post a Comment